Best Insurance Companies in New York (2026)
We ranked the top 5 insurance companies for owner-operators and fleets in New York (NY). Scores based on pricing, service, technology, and northeast regional fit.
Top 5 Insurance Companies for New York Truckers
Progressive Commercial
84/100Best for: Best Overall
Progressive Commercial is the largest commercial auto insurer in the United States, covering everything from single owner-operators to large fleets. Their digital-first approach, competitive quoting e...
Great West Casualty
82/100Best for: Long-Haul Carriers
Great West Casualty Company has been insuring truckers since 1956 and is one of the most respected names in commercial trucking insurance. Based in South Sioux City, Nebraska, they specialize exclusiv...
OOIDA Insurance
81/100Best for: Owner-Operators
OOIDA (Owner-Operator Independent Drivers Association) provides insurance programs exclusively for its members — independent owner-operators and small fleet owners. As a member-driven association, OOI...
Northland Insurance
80/100Best for: Small Fleets
Northland Insurance Company, a Travelers subsidiary, specializes in commercial trucking and transportation insurance for small to mid-size operations. They're known for competitive pricing for fleets ...
National Indemnity
79/100Best for: Financial Stability
National Indemnity Company is Berkshire Hathaway's flagship insurance subsidiary and one of the most financially stable insurers on the planet. While they're not exclusively a trucking insurer, their ...
Why These Insurance Companies Work Best in New York
The Northeast's dense population, high freight volume, and toll-heavy corridors create specific demands for insurance companies in New York. We evaluated each product against criteria that matter most to NY owner-operators: compatibility with finance freight, support for operations along I-87, and value relative to the state's 24.17c/gal fuel tax and very high freight volume.
New York-Specific Buying Considerations
New York's lake-effect snow buffalo/syracuse; nyc congestion legendary affect insurance rates — carriers with clean records get better premiums
Toll road exposure in NY can affect premium calculations
Truck parking availability is critical shortage in New York — consider coverage for overnight parking incidents
Insurers familiar with northeast freight patterns can offer more competitive rates for NY carriers
Score Comparison
| Rank | Product | Score | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|
| #1 | Progressive Commercial | 84/100 | Best Overall |
| #2 | Great West Casualty | 82/100 | Long-Haul Carriers |
| #3 | OOIDA Insurance | 81/100 | Owner-Operators |
| #4 | Northland Insurance | 80/100 | Small Fleets |
| #5 | National Indemnity | 79/100 | Financial Stability |
Free pricing comparison
Get NY-specific pricing on the top insurance companies
We'll pull current rates from our top insurance companies for New York carriers — including Progressive Commercial — and send a one-page side-by-side. No sales calls.
One email. We may follow up about dispatch services. See our privacy policy.
Or browse the full lineup
Side-by-side comparisons, detailed pricing breakdowns, and in-depth reviews of all 10 insurance companies we've evaluated.